Our opinion is that the York YC2D (13.4 SEER2) air conditioner makes the most sense for use in Rochester NY. Many sales people will tell you that a higher SEER unit will pay for itself in the way of energy savings. This is true, but homeowners need to consider the climate in Rochester, and the price difference between different air conditioners. In Rochester, we use our air conditioners for a very small portion of the year (versus somewhere like Arizona), which means that the payback period typically exceeds the life expectancy of the air conditioner, and does not justify the increase cost of the unit.

In general, a higher SEER rating indicates a more energy-efficient air conditioner. So, one might assume that a 17 SEER air conditioner would be more advantageous than a 14 SEER unit. However, several factors can influence the decision of which air conditioner makes more sense for a particular situation:

  1. Cost: Typically, higher SEER-rated air conditioners are more expensive upfront compared to lower SEER-rated models.
  2. Climate: The local climate plays a role in determining the cost-effectiveness of a higher SEER rating. In regions with long and hot summers, where the air conditioner operates frequently, the energy savings from a higher SEER unit can be more significant and offset the higher initial cost. In milder climates or areas with shorter cooling seasons (like Rochester), the energy savings may not be as substantial.
  3. Energy costs: The price of electricity in your area affects the potential savings of a higher SEER unit. If electricity rates are low, the energy savings from a higher SEER air conditioner may not make a substantial difference in overall costs.
  4. Usage patterns: If you use your air conditioner infrequently or for shorter periods, the energy savings from a higher SEER unit may not justify the increased cost.

It’s important to consider your specific circumstances, including your budget, climate, and energy usage patterns when choosing an air conditioner. Feel free to contact us for a free consultation, and we can provide you with some recommendations and guidance for your specific home and situation.